David Sylvian: Blemish

Editor's Choice

Rating: ★★★

Record and Artist Details

Manafon

Musicians:

John Tilbury (p)
Michael Moser (clo)
Evan Parker (ts, ss)
Werner Dafeldecker (b)
Otomo Yoshihide (g, turntables)
Christian Fennesz (el g, elec)
Sachiko Matsubara (elec)
Marcio Mattos (clo)
David Sylvian (v, g, ky, elec)
Keith Rowe (el g)
Franz Hautzinger (t)
Tetuzi Akiyama (g, el g)
Buckhardt Stangl (el g)

Label:

Samadhisound/UMC

October/2022

Media Format:

2 LP, DL

Catalogue Number:

3876876

RecordDate:

Rec. 2004–2007

Musicians:

Derek Bailey (el g)
Christian Fennesz (elec)
David Sylvian (v, prod)

Label:

Samadhisound/UMC

October/2022

Media Format:

LP, DL

Catalogue Number:

3876873

RecordDate:

Rec. February–March 2003

David Sylvian's journey from pretty pop idol to the outer reaches of the avant-garde is equalled by few other musicians: the late great Scott Walker for one, Julie Driscoll/Tippetts perhaps another. Sylvian (born Dave Batt) found huge success with the androgynous pop group Japan in the late 1970s and early 80s, but following their split, began a long voyage into the experimental realm with a series of increasingly challenging solo albums, shedding much of his original audience along the way (as Walker did).

It's a measure of both the respect he commands and his openness to new ideas that throughout his career, Sylvian has managed to attract the services of first-rate musicians such as Kenny Wheeler, Holger Czukay, Ryuichi Sakamoto, Jon Hassell, Robert Fripp, Bill Nelson, David Torn, Mark Isham and Danny Thomson, and these two albums see him rounding up a number of free-music titans, notably Derek Bailey, Evan Parker and Keith Rowe.

Blemish, the first album made after his split with Virgin Records, was originally released online, then as a very limited LP and CD; making this superb-sounding vinyl reissue extremely welcome. It's a starkly beautiful record, entirely improvised with Bailey and, unusually for Sylvian, lyrically and vocally direct (both his career and personal life were unravelling at the time), with Bailey's jarring, percussive plucking and his feedback drones providing the perfect accompaniment to the singer's anguish.

In fact, the late guitarist's extraordinary playing (given added texture by Fennesz's electronic manipulations) is jaw-dropping in its inventiveness, virtuosity and sensitivity. Bailey and Sylvian made truly beautiful music together, and it's a pity they didn’t make more of it.

Manafon, recorded with a larger cast over a longer period of time, feels more diffuse, less focused, but no less forbidding. Again, the collaborators – principally Rowe, Parker and Fennesz – are well-chosen; they provide suitably spiky yet restrained and sympathetic improvised backing for Sylvian's musings (calling them ‘songs’ feels like a bit of a stretch), the best of which is the 11-minute album centrepiece ‘The Greatest Living Englishman’.

Again, an appreciated (and splendid-sounding) reissue for a now-very-pricey original.

Follow us

Jazzwise Print

  • Latest print issues

From £5.83 / month

Subscribe

Jazzwise Digital Club

  • Latest digital issues
  • Digital archive since 1997
  • Download tracks from bonus compilation albums during the year
  • Reviews Database access

From £7.42 / month

Subscribe

Subscribe from only £5.83

Never miss an issue of the UK's biggest selling jazz magazine.

Subscribe

View the Current
Issue

Take a peek inside the latest issue of Jazzwise magazine.

Find out more